1974 No. 1 Hit Voted One of the ‘Worst Songs of All Time'

While not every hit song is equally appreciated years (or decades) down the line, one CNN poll highlighted a surprisingly harsh view of a '70s classic with a heartbreaking origin story.

"Seasons in the Sun," a 1974 Terry Jacks cover of a 1961 Jacques Brel song of the same name, was a #1 hit in 10 countries, from the United Kingdom to Zimbabwe, and the then-West Germany to Australia, sitting atop the Billboard Hot 100 in the U.S. for three weeks. Translated by fellow musician Rod McKuen from French to English, Jacks significantly rewrote several parts of the song to better reflect a personal experience.

Jacks' friend, reportedly named Roger, served as a significant source for the Canadian singer's rewrite, following his death from leukemia. Brel's version, which translates to "The Dying Man," was from a similar perspective of a man on his deathbed, but Jacks' soft rock version erased translated lyrics involving a wife, such as "I want people to dance / when they put me in a hole," or "Farewell Antoine, I did not like you" and instead opted for a less macabre take which focused on friendship and idyllic childhood memories.

Jacks' easy-listening take certainly won over the hearts of listeners upon its success upon commercial release in 1974, ranking number two on Billboard's year-end charts. However, music lovers thirty years later didn't feel quite the same way. In a 2006 CNN viewer poll, the song was #5 on their "Worst Song of All Time" list, with contributors adding that it was "an all-time piece of dreck," and "a melody you couldn't play for your dog combined with inane lyrics."

The new millennium likely saw a greater cynicism for Jacks' more sanitised version of a man's final moments on this earth, with a new generation viewing it as a cringeworthy, overtly twee song loved by their parents. However, Jacks' depiction of a beloved friend and their cherished memories, coupled with the backdrop of the growing cultural backlash against the violence of the Vietnam War in the early 1970s, offers a valid explanation for why audiences would resonate with Jacks' cover more than the French-language original, full of bitterness, morbidity, and — oddly enough — accusations of infidelity from the narrator.

.

source https://www.mensjournal.com/news/1974-no-1-hit-voted-one-of-the-worst-songs-of-all-time